All-Americans
| Stags | Year(s) |
Athenas |
Year(s) |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brian Barnes | 1991 | Mary Tracey | 1980 | |
| Matt Newman | 1995 | Cindy Nagle | 1981,82,83,84 | |
| Eli Klovee-Smith | 2000 | Liane Kivela | 1984,87 | |
| David Juiliano | 2001 | Brigid Stirling | 1987 | |
| Pat McGrail | 2002 | Louise Tench | 1996 | |
| Zorg Loustalet | 2013,14,15 | Yarrow Moench | 1997 | |
| Kyle Lund | 2016 | Ellie Irons | 2000 | |
| Joshua Sealand | 2016 | Angela Jacquez | 2001,02,03 | |
| Thomas D'Anieri | 2019 | Andrea Haver | 2001 | |
| Henry Pick | 2021 | Kim Sonne | 2005 | |
| Stevie Steinberg | 2021 | Jennifer Tavé | 2009,10 | |
| Breanna Deutsch | 2011 | |||
| Bridget Blum | 2012,15 | |||
| Allison Barnwell | 2012,13 | |||
| Bryn McKillop | 2016,17 | |||
| Riley Harmon | 2019,21 | |||
| Meredith Bloss | 2021 | |||
| Natalie Bitetti | 2021,22,23 | |||
| Emily Clarke | 2021 | |||
| Riley Capuano | 2023 | |||
| Elle Marsyla | 2023 |