First Team All-SCIAC
+ = SCIAC Champion; ^ = SCIAC Runner of the Year
| Men | Year | Men | Year | |
| Ed Laughton | 1959,60+,61 | Pat Conroy | 1970,71 | |
| Terry Chappell | 1971 | Wayne Akiyama | 1971,72,73 | |
| Steve Rodriguez | 1973 | Billy Johnson | 1974 | |
| Paul Cronin | 1977 | Bob Gallagher | 1978 | |
| Gregg Bronn | 1985 | Mike Scott | 1986+^,87^,88 | |
| Carl Berg | 1987,88,89+ | Brian Barnes | 1988,89,90,91 | |
| Eric Blum | 1989 | John Dennis | 1989 | |
| Jeff Peterson | 1989 | Ray Butman | 1992 | |
| Brad Aagaard | 1993^ | Jason Rhodes | 1993 | |
| Walter Voegtli | 1994,96 | Matt Newman | 1994,95 | |
| James Uwins | 1995,96 | Eli Klovee-Smith | 1997,98,99,00+^ | |
| Steve Alves | 1997,98,99 | David Boland | 1997 | |
| Jeff Liebert | 1997 | Jason Rogers | 1998,99 | |
| Richard Chisholm | 1998 | Elisha Peterson | 1998,99 | |
| Blaine Hunt | 2000 | Pat McGrail | 2000,01,02+^ | |
| Jose Gomez | 2000,01,02 | Karl Mahlburg | 2000 | |
| David Juiliano | 2001+^ | Will Berriel | 2001,02 | |
| Dan Phiffer | 2001 | Matt MacLeod | 2001,02 | |
| Nathan Kurtz | 2001 | Kevin Andrew | 2002 | |
| Dan Hayman | 2003,04,05,06 | Mike Van Antwerp | 2005,06,07 | |
| Brian Koczynski | 2007 | Adam Coleman | 2007 | |
| Chris Gurney | 2007 | Brad Johnson | 2007 |
| Women | Year | Women | Year | |
| Kathy Evans | 1977 | Mary Tracey | 1978,79+,80+ | |
| Jeana West | 1978,79,80 | Carol Patejdle | 1978 | |
| Mari Carisetti | 1980 | Cindy Nagle | 1981+^,82+^,83+^,84+^ | |
| Wendy Wallace | 1982,84 | Ann Scott | 1983,85 | |
| Liane Kivela | 1984,85,86,87 | Sheilagh Boyle | 1985,86 | |
| Brigid Stirling | 1986,87 | Kristy Armstrong | 1986 | |
| Ashley Orton | 1987,88 | Cheryl Bonner | 1987 | |
| Diane Pettit | 1987,89 | Carol Wawrukiewicz | 1988 | |
| Rhoda Roberts | 1988,89 | Charlie Stoddard | 1990 | |
| Sarah Gerard | 1992,95 | Gretchen Brugman | 1992,93,94 | |
| Gretchen Sauer | 1993,94 | Shoshana Ziblatt | 1993,95 | |
| Jennifer Stuart | 1994+,95,97 | Louise Tench | 1995^,96+^ | |
| Jennie Davis | 1995 | Yarrow Moench | 1996,97+^ | |
| Sedina Banks | 1996,97,98 | Pavla Dusek | 1997,98 | |
| Brandi Page | 1997,98,99 | Nicole Scheunemann | 1997 | |
| Shelby Johnson | 1998 | Andrea Haver | 1998,99+ | |
| Jodie Konigsberg | 1998 | Amy Foss | 1999,00,01 | |
| Ellie Irons | 1999,00,01 | Angela Jacquez | 2000,01,02+^,03+^ | |
| Sarah Alaei | 2000,02,03 | Megan Olson | 2000 | |
| Danae Wright | 2000 | Kim Sonne | 2002,03,05* | |
| Elizabeth Tedsen | 2002,03,04 | Amy Berg | 2004,05 | |
| Sarah McFadden | 2004,05 | Lindsay Burt | 2004 | |
| Katie Mouzakis | 2006 | Evelyn Ross | 2006,07 | |
| Brittany Nunnink | 2006 |
